On Wednesday morning, a South Utica renter named Jan said she went to City Court over a dispute about repairs to her home. That evening, she stood before the Utica Common Council and asked members to hear what the dispute had meant for her. Later that night, the council voted 5–4 against adopting New York’s Good Cause Eviction protections.
“You’ve all been listening to each other. Now I want you to listen to reality,” Jan told the council. She described serious health concerns she attributed to mold in her home. Her account of the conditions and their effect on her health could not be independently verified.

Senya Bekui (left), Citizen Action of New York lead organizer, and Shana Dahlin (right), the organization’s board president. Submitted photograph.
Jan spoke during nearly 45 minutes of public comment from tenants, advocates and landlords. Earlier, Citizen Action of New York rallied outside City Hall in support of the proposal. The vote followed months of organizing and debate. The council first moved to set another public hearing, then brought the proposal out of committee for an immediate vote. The hearing was canceled after the measure failed.
How Utica councilors voted on Good Cause Eviction
- In favor (4) — Katie Aiello (First Ward), Venice Ervin (Fifth Ward), Heather Wasielewski and Jack LoMedico (both at-large).
- Against (5) — Robert Burmaster (Second Ward), Joseph Betar (Third Ward), Frank Carcone (Fourth Ward), Joseph Betrus (Sixth Ward) and Samantha Colosimo-Testa (at-large).
Betar, who represents Jan’s ward, told the council that more than 4,300 units already have other housing protections and would be exempt. He called for stronger code enforcement, accountability for unresolved violations and work to address lead hazards. Betrus said he viewed the measure as duplicative and an added burden for landlords. Property owners who opposed it cited rising costs, eviction expenses and the effect of additional rules on owners who maintain their buildings.
Aiello, who backed Good Cause Eviction, said landlords would still have legal grounds to evict tenants for reasons such as nonpayment of rent and serious lease violations. Senya Bekui, a Central New York organizer with Citizen Action, argued that the measure would give tenants who meet their rental obligations another safeguard against losing their homes.
What Good Cause Eviction would have changed
New York’s 2024 law applies in New York City and in municipalities that opt in. In a covered apartment, a landlord generally needs a reason recognized by law to evict a tenant or refuse to renew a lease. The end of a lease alone generally would not be enough. The law also gives covered tenants a way to challenge certain rent increases in court. Some homes are exempt, including many rent-regulated and income-restricted units. Coverage also depends on factors such as ownership and building type. The New York attorney general’s guide explains the grounds and exemptions.
For a renter whose apartment would have qualified, Good Cause Eviction could have made a difference at lease renewal. For a renter trying to get an unsafe condition fixed, the city’s inspection and enforcement process would still matter. Both problems came up at City Hall.
Where Utica renters can turn for help
Utica’s vote against Good Cause Eviction leaves existing tenant protections in place. The Legal Aid Society of Mid-New York’s Tenant Defense Project helps eligible renters with eviction defense and unsafe housing conditions. Oneida County renters can apply online or call 877-777-6152.
Jan came to City Hall asking councilors to hear what happens when a repair dispute reaches court. What residents will be watching now is whether the city follows through on the stronger enforcement some councilors called for, and how renters will be able to tell if it is working.
Meeting reference: Nov. 18 Utica Common Council meeting summary. Previous VoiceMV coverage: Utica’s housing debate before the vote. Featured photo: Utica City Hall in a 2021 file photo by Kenneth C. Zirkel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.



