Independent news.
A shared sense of place.

How Florence’s Black Farming Settlement Laid Claim to a Vote

by Dawn Michelle Laguerre | Nov 19, 2026 | Black Perspective, Mohawk Valley

Deeds, newspaper notices and an 1858 map show how Black settlers used land to build a community and challenge a voting barrier in Oneida County.

In the 1840s, Black families began putting down roots in the Florence Farming Settlement in northern Oneida County. They were building farms and households, but land meant something more in New York at the time. The state required Black men to own at least $250 in property to vote. White men did not face the same property test. Under that unequal rule, a deed could be a step toward a voice in government.

Stephen Myers helped organize a community

Stephen Myers, a Black abolitionist, newspaper editor and Underground Railroad organizer from Albany, helped lead the project with Gerrit Smith, an abolitionist and major landowner from Peterboro. The National Park Service’s account of Stephen and Harriet Myers places the Florence Farming and Lumber Association alongside Stephen Myers’s work for voting rights and equal education. Smith helped make land available. Myers helped turn the idea into an organized effort.

There is no need to pick a single birthday for the settlement. The Oneida County Underground Railroad study dates the organization and land work to 1846. An 1847 newspaper notice called for a January 1848 convention on settling the land. The historic marker dates the community to about 1848–1860. Those records mark different stages: setting the project in motion and building a place where families lived.

The land was an opportunity, not a promise

The New York State Museum explains that the project joined two goals: helping Black men meet the property threshold and giving families a chance to support themselves. But holding land did not guarantee a living from it. In a letter to Frederick Douglass discussed in the county history study, Myers described stony soil and heavy timber, as well as land suitable for oats, corn and grazing.

Myers and Douglass did not see the settlement in exactly the same way. In the New York State Archives Partnership Trust’s teaching materials, Douglass’s letter expresses doubts about the undertaking. Myers’s reply makes the case for its prospects. Read together, they show leaders weighing the practical demands of moving and farming, not a community that was ever assured of success.

Closed ledger and dip pen on a sunlit desk
A ledger and dip pen symbolize the records historians use to trace the settlement. AI-generated editorial illustration by Mohawk Valley Voice; not an archival artifact.

What one settler’s life tells us

Walter Hawkins, who escaped enslavement in Washington, D.C., settled in Florence in 1849, according to the county history study. The study traces his route through Buffalo and New Bedford, Massachusetts, before he reached Oneida County. He later left with his family for Canada after the Fugitive Slave Act and became a bishop in the British Methodist Episcopal Church. S. J. Celestine Edwards recorded Hawkins’s account of his life in an 1891 biography. The archive lesson includes an excerpt about his years farming.

Hawkins’s story helps explain a distinction the marker alone might miss. Florence was not simply a stop on a route out of slavery. It was a place where people tried to make a lasting home. It did not remove the threat posed by federal law. Nor does the record show that every settler secured voting rights. The surviving evidence is clearer about the effort families made than about every individual outcome.

How to see the records for yourself

Start with Gillette’s 1858 map of Oneida County at the Library of Congress. The state archive lesson uses a section of that map to trace farms near land owned by Myers. Pair it with the convention notice to see the difference between an invitation to settle and the evidence that people acquired and occupied land. Families, teachers and students can use the lesson’s documents and questions without traveling.

The marker’s sponsor lists its location on Florence Hill Road near Florence Hill State Forest. The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation says the forest has no formal hiking trails. Treat the marker as a point of reference, not directions to accessible ruins. The State Museum’s podcast page offers another way in, with perspectives from a Camden teacher, a local historian and an archaeologist.

Have a local history source we should look at next? Write to news@voicemv.com.

Featured image: Hands hold soil over a field, symbolizing the work of building a farming community. AI-generated editorial illustration by Mohawk Valley Voice; not a historical image.

Get new VoiceMV stories by email

Enter your email to receive new Mohawk Valley Voice posts. You can unsubscribe at any time.

MOHAWK VALLEY WEATHER
Loading local weather…

National Weather Service · Full forecast ↗

Advertisement

Utica Store
Maroon Union Station Utica T-shirt from Utica Store

Wear your hometown.

Discover Union Station designs and more Utica-inspired favorites.

Black Utica EST 1832 dad hat from Utica Store

Bring your Utica pride.

Top off your everyday look with a hometown classic.

Visit Utica Store →

Advertise with the Voice

Recent Posts

Community Announcements

Have a public meeting, nonprofit event, community update or local announcement to share?

Send it to the newsroom →