Independent news.
A shared sense of place.

Court Enters $534,550 Judgment Against Oneonta Vape Shop Operators

by Dawn Michelle Laguerre | Nov 20, 2026 | NY Attorney General, Courts & Cases

A civil judgment adds penalties and costs to an earlier injunction. The state says the order bars the operators from selling vapes anywhere in New York.

The Oneonta vape shop judgment orders the operators of three stores to pay $534,550 in a New York civil case. The signed judgment was entered Nov. 10 in Otsego County. Attorney General Letitia James announced the result Nov. 20 and said the court had ordered the stores closed and barred the operators from selling vapes in New York.

The ruling is the latest step in a case that began in October 2025. It concerns Pop-In Smoke & Vape, Pufftopia and Royalty Tobacco, along with their principals, Eysa Sharhan and Ahmed Mozeb. The civil case is distinct from a criminal prosecution. The court’s order and the attorney general’s account also do not establish when the stores physically closed or whether the respondents have paid.

What the Oneonta vape shop judgment requires

Justice Brian D. Burns signed the Oneonta vape shop judgment Nov. 4. The court entered $514,500 in penalties, $10,050 in outstanding state Department of Health fines and $10,000 in court costs. The fines came from four administrative decisions in 2022 and 2023. The larger penalty amount covers violations and stipulations listed in the judgment, spanning 2023 through September 2025.

The penalties and health department fines accrue 9% annual interest after judgment, according to the order. The court also held the respondents responsible for the safe disposal costs of flavored vape products left at Royalty Tobacco. The Oneonta vape shop judgment does not set that amount, so it is not included in the $534,550.

The closure order came before the dollar amount

The November judgment cites an April 13 decision that granted part of the state’s petition and ordered injunctive relief. That is a court order requiring people or businesses to do or stop doing something. The attorney general’s office says the earlier relief bars the respondents from selling, marketing or distributing vapes, holding a vape license or running a business that sells vapes. The office also says it requires the operators to remove the products and close their State Highway 7 stores.

AI-generated illustration for the Oneonta vape shop judgment showing papers overlooking imagined storefronts.
AI-generated illustration by Mohawk Valley Voice. The storefronts are imaginary and do not show the Oneonta businesses.

The state filed its petition in October 2025 after a multiyear Department of Health investigation. The attorney general’s office said inspectors documented repeated underage sales and unlawful sales of flavored vapes, and that the businesses reopened under different names after enforcement actions. A temporary order restricting flavored vape sales followed on Oct. 24, 2025. The court later let the state seek monetary relief in writing instead of holding an in-person hearing.

The filing date matters: the attorney general announced the outcome Nov. 20, but that was not the day the court entered judgment or proof of the date the stores shut their doors. The record separates those steps: the injunction governs what the respondents may do, while the later monetary judgment sets most of what they owe. The case is listed under index EF2025-899. The current status of any appeal or stay has not been independently verified. No public response from the respondents was located.

What families and retailers should know

New York prohibits retail sales of flavored vapor products with nicotine and bars sales of nicotine products to anyone under 21. Both protections apply beyond Otsego County. The state Department of Health’s vaping guide explains the rules and offers resources for families and retailers.

For teens and young adults who already vape and want to stop, the department points to DropTheVape, a confidential text-based support program. The New York State Quitline also offers free, confidential support at 1-866-697-8487. Families can share those resources without waiting for a school disciplinary issue or treating a child’s request for help as a reason for punishment.

Get new VoiceMV stories by email

Enter your email to receive new Mohawk Valley Voice posts. You can unsubscribe at any time.

MOHAWK VALLEY WEATHER
Loading local weather…

National Weather Service · Full forecast ↗

Advertisement

Utica Store
Maroon Union Station Utica T-shirt from Utica Store

Wear your hometown.

Discover Union Station designs and more Utica-inspired favorites.

Black Utica EST 1832 dad hat from Utica Store

Bring your Utica pride.

Top off your everyday look with a hometown classic.

Visit Utica Store →

Advertise with the Voice

Recent Posts

Community Announcements

Have a public meeting, nonprofit event, community update or local announcement to share?

Send it to the newsroom →