The mayor announced 10 new selections related to NYC judicial selections and six prospective reappointments. The official hearing notice lists five Criminal Court and five Family Court nominees for November 17.
By David Laguerre
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced 16 prospective judicial appointments and reappointments on November 16, including 10 new judges, following recommendations from the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary regarding NYC judicial selections.
The announcement concerns New York City’s Criminal and Family Courts, not courts in Utica or elsewhere in the Mohawk Valley. It is a state justice-system story, but it does not change a local judicial seat.
The city’s press release describes the selections as prospective. It should not be read as evidence that every candidate has already taken office.
What the hearing notice says
A November 9 notice from the advisory committee sets two sessions for Tuesday, November 17, at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, 100 Church Street, 12th Floor, Manhattan.
The Criminal Court session is scheduled for 10 a.m. Eastern. Its nominees are Alexis Flyer, Molly Gallivan, William Kendall, Hana Kim and Melissa Medilien. The Family Court session is scheduled for 1 p.m. Eastern. That list names Mary Cheng, Brian Holbrook, Beth Krause, Danielle Rodriguez and Deana Tietjen.
The notice required signed written statements intended for presentation by 10 a.m. Monday, November 16. That deadline has passed. The document does not establish an extension, so readers should not assume that a late submission will be accepted.
The notice also explains that written statements are provided to candidates before the hearing. People considering participation should review that disclosure rather than assume their submissions will remain private.
A distinction that needs clarification
The mayor’s release says all 16 prospective appointments and reappointments will be subject to the November 17 hearing. The committee’s notice, however, names only the 10 new nominees.
That distinction is also reflected in Executive Order 6, issued January 2. Its public-hearing provision exempts incumbent reappointments from the required hearing. The documents therefore do not support treating the hearing notice as a 16-person schedule.
The six prospective reappointments named in the release are Tamiko Amaker, Toni Cimino, Valentina Morales, Jennifer Saint-Preux, Joseph Sorrentino and Juanita E. Wing.
How the screening process works
Executive Order 6 gives the advisory committee responsibility for recruiting, evaluating and recommending candidates. Its review considers qualifications, experience, temperament and commitment to equal justice, and nominees are referred to the Department of Investigation for screening.
The order permits people to present information about a nominee’s fitness at a public hearing. The committee may reconsider a nomination in light of what it receives and must notify the mayor if a nomination is withdrawn.
The order also requires public information about the stages of evaluation and general assessment criteria, annual aggregate reporting and a searchable record of judicial appointees. Individual application materials, references and deliberations remain subject to confidentiality protections.
Those requirements describe the selection process. They are not findings about how a particular nominee will rule in future cases, and official statements praising candidates should not be mistaken for independent evaluations of their future performance.
Follow the official record
Readers can consult the linked hearing notice for the announced schedule and the mayor’s release for candidate biographies. Final appointments and any updated hearing information should be checked against the committee’s public record before treating a prospective selection as completed.


