Independent news.
A shared sense of place.

New York Thanksgiving Dinner Costs Fall as U.S. Average Rises

by Dawn Michelle Laguerre | Nov 21, 2026 | Money & Household, Mohawk Valley

New York Thanksgiving dinner cost moved in the opposite direction from the U.S. average in this year’s Farm Bureau survey.

The staples for a Thanksgiving dinner for 10 averaged $59.59 in this year’s New York Farm Bureau survey, down $6.47 from its 2025 total. The national survey went the other way: Its $58.63 average was about 6% higher than a year ago. Even with the opposite year-to-year moves, New York’s basket still cost 96 cents more than the U.S. average.

For shoppers in Utica, Rome and nearby towns, the split is a reminder to price the meal they actually plan to serve rather than using either average as a target every store should meet. The surveys capture an early-November snapshot, not a quote from a neighborhood supermarket. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, Nov. 26, so a price checked in the survey may differ from an offer on your shopping day.

Why the New York basket fell

The biggest change in the New York Farm Bureau’s state survey was the turkey. A 16-pound frozen bird averaged $21.86 in New York, or about $1.37 a pound, down 23% from the state’s prior survey. The same size bird averaged $23.68 nationally, or $1.48 a pound, an increase of about 10%.

Not every part of the dinner followed the turkey. New York’s surveyed gallon of whole milk held at $4.07. A dozen dinner rolls averaged $4.45, down 2% in New York but still more than the $3.81 national average. Two frozen pie crusts averaged $3.99 in the state, compared with $3.28 nationally.

The American Farm Bureau Federation’s analysis puts the national figure below the $64.05 recorded in 2022, even after this year’s increase. That comparison is useful for understanding the survey over time; it does not describe what happened across grocery departments or what any one household spent.

New York survey averages: $21.86 for a 16-pound turkey, $4.45 for a dozen dinner rolls and $3.99 for two frozen pie crusts.
VoiceMV graphic using New York Farm Bureau survey averages, not local store quotes.

What $59.59 does, and doesn’t, buy

Volunteers checked prices in the first week of November using a set shopping list. The basket includes items such as a frozen turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes, rolls, cranberries, milk and pie ingredients. It is not a menu for every household. If you add ham, buy a prepared dessert, serve drinks or need ingredients for a family recipe, price those separately. If you already have pantry staples or are sharing dishes with guests, your checkout cost could be lower than the value of the entire meal.

The state figure also tells us nothing definite about what was available in a particular Mohawk Valley store, what shoppers will pay closer to the holiday or whether regular grocery prices have fallen overall. The New York Farm Bureau itself warns against reading a limited volunteer survey as a statewide grocery-price trend. The same item can also cost different amounts depending on brand, package size and the rules of a promotion.

New York dinner for ten averaged $66.06 in 2025 and $59.59 in 2026; the 2026 U.S. average was $58.63.
VoiceMV graphic. Sources: New York Farm Bureau and the American Farm Bureau Federation.

How to use the survey at the store

  1. Start with the turkey’s total price. Multiply the advertised price per pound by the weight on the package. Check for a minimum purchase, loyalty account, digital coupon or limit before comparing that total with another store.
  2. Compare like with like. Separate a whole frozen bird from a fresh turkey or a prepared dinner. For rolls, milk and pie crusts, compare the actual sizes and number of servings rather than the sale price alone.
  3. Check the full basket before making a second trip. The lower price on one item may not make the rest of the list cheaper. Compare the purchases you still need to make, not the price of items you already have.

For readers working with a tight budget, VoiceMV’s Thanksgiving food assistance coverage has a different purpose: finding local meal or grocery options rather than comparing supermarket prices. Check the organizer’s hours and current availability before heading out.

Thanksgiving roast turkey. Photo by Holly Cheng via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Get new VoiceMV stories by email

Enter your email to receive new Mohawk Valley Voice posts. You can unsubscribe at any time.

MOHAWK VALLEY WEATHER
Loading local weather…

National Weather Service · Full forecast ↗

Advertisement

Utica Store
Maroon Union Station Utica T-shirt from Utica Store

Wear your hometown.

Discover Union Station designs and more Utica-inspired favorites.

Black Utica EST 1832 dad hat from Utica Store

Bring your Utica pride.

Top off your everyday look with a hometown classic.

Visit Utica Store →

Advertise with the Voice

Recent Posts

Community Announcements

Have a public meeting, nonprofit event, community update or local announcement to share?

Send it to the newsroom →