ELMIRA, NYÂ – The New York State Police at SP Horseheads announced the arrest of two individuals on July 2, 2025, in connection with predatory sexual assault charges involving a 1-year-old victim.
Arrest Details
Grace E. Balthazor, 33, of Elmira, NY, and Devin G. Lavalley, 37, of Burlington Flats, NY, were arrested and charged with:
- Predatory Sexual Assault Against a Child (Class A-II Felony)
- Use of a Child in a Sexual Performance (Class C Felony)
The arrests followed an investigation into a sexual assault that occurred against a 1-year-old female victim, along with the video recording of the incident.
Court Proceedings
Both suspects were arraigned in the City of Elmira Court, where they were remanded to the Chemung County Jail with no bail set. They remain in custody pending future court action.
Investigation Details
The New York State Police at SP Horseheads led the investigation with assistance from:
- State Police Computer Crimes Unit
- New York State Police at SP Sidney Bureau of Criminal Investigation Unit
The involvement of the Computer Crimes Unit suggests digital evidence played a significant role in the case.
Legal Context
Under New York State law, Predatory Sexual Assault Against a Child is one of the most serious felony charges, carrying potential sentences of 10-25 years to life in prison. The charge of Use of a Child in a Sexual Performance relates to the creation or possession of child sexual abuse material.
Ongoing Investigation
New York State Police have indicated this remains an ongoing investigation. Both defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
