A lifelong fan’s take on the first reactions to James Gunn’s Superman and what it means for the new DC Universe

By David LaGuerre- Self proclaimed Geek/ Nerd

Superman is back—and this time, he’s bringing hope with him. As someone who grew up immersed in sci‑fi, tech, and comic book culture, from watching the 60’s Batman TV show live to collecting early comic books, I can say that this reboot of an icon feels personal. Today’s film, directed by James Gunn, delivers a thrilling start to the new DC Universe. Early reviews have hailed it as a “terrific start” with critics raving about its soaring visuals and heartwarming themes. With David Corenswet’s Superman and Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane receiving widespread admiration for their “off the charts” chemistry, here’s why this film is resonating with fans and critics alike.

The Dawn of a New Superman Era

A Return to Hope and Humanity

In Gunn’s Superman (2025), the character is reimagined as a beacon of hope and kindness. The film centers on the timeless values of moral clarity and compassion, qualities that have defined Superman since he first appeared in the comic books. James Gunn emphasizes that Superman’s story is not just one of superhuman strength, but rather a celebration of the immigrant experience. By framing the hero as arriving on Earth from another world—a metaphor for the immigrant journey—Gunn situates the character as a symbol of hope amid adversity. Critics note that this fresh take taps into a universal need for optimism, particularly in turbulent times.

Comic Book Magic on the Big Screen

Gunn’s vision strives to capture the magic and colorful energy of classic comic books. Reviewers have praised the film’s ability to transform pages into a cinematic spectacle that feels as exhilarating as opening a vibrant comic for the first time. Bright visuals, adrenaline-pumping action sequences, and a storyline steeped in heart all contribute to an experience that both honors Superman’s heritage and reinvents his narrative for modern audiences. Many have remarked that the film is a “comic book brought to life,” filled with wonder and playful homage to the genre’s roots.

First Reactions: Soaring Hopes and High Praise

Chemistry and Performances

At the center of this new chapter is the performance of David Corenswet as Superman. Critics have been quick to praise his portrayal as both sincere and powerful—qualities that are essential for a character tasked with embodying hope. His dual role as Clark Kent and Superman is executed with a surprising sensitivity that appeals even to longtime fans. Equally compelling is Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane, whose spirited portrayal brings an infectious energy to the film. Their chemistry has been described as “off the charts,” a testament to their natural rapport that breathes life into every scene.

One enthusiastic review quoted,
“Superman made me so damn happy… the world needs this movie and we can all learn so much from Superman.”
Another noted, “David Corenswet was born for Superman and Clark Kent,” capturing the essence of what makes this depiction so magical.

Even the film’s lighter moments are memorable. Krypto the Superdog, a character that unexpectedly steals the spotlight, offers both charm and comic relief, reminding viewers that even heroes have a playful side.

A New Vision for DC

James Gunn’s approach isn’t merely about reimagining a beloved classic—it’s about redefining an entire universe. Unlike the darker, more introspective iterations of the past, this film reintroduces Superman as a hero with an unwavering moral compass, a living testament to the idea that even in a modern, complex world, hope remains essential.

Gunn has stated that this film is “the story of America,” interweaving themes of immigration, moral courage, and the importance of kindness. By taking inspiration from celebrated comic series such as Grant Morrison’s All-Star Superman, the movie bridges the gap between the nostalgia of past legends and the fresh perspectives needed for future storytelling. With its grounded narrative intertwined with comic book fantasy, this reboot not only reclaims Superman’s optimistic spirit but also sets a promising tone for the new DC Universe.

What This Means for Fans and the Genre

A Fresh Start for the DC Universe

For longtime devotees of comic book lore and those new to the genre, Superman (2025) marks the dawn of a new era. It is the first film in an ambitious, interconnected DC Universe that pledges to offer stories which are both visually spectacular and rich in moral substance. By positioning hope, kindness, and authenticity at its core, the film provides a blueprint for future projects—a universe where heroes are not merely larger-than-life figures, but aspirational symbols of everyday values.

Cultural and Fan Impact

The cultural impact of this reboot is already resonating within the comic book community and on social media. Fans across various platforms have expressed excitement, heartwarming nostalgia, and even a sense of renewal. Hashtags like #Superman2025 and #JamesGunnSuperman are trending, as aficionados debate new storylines and share their personal connections to the character.

This film’s message of inclusion and optimism particularly appeals to those who have long identified with Superman as a symbol of hope in difficult times. It bridges generational divides: older fans are delighted to see a return to the classic ideals of heroism, while younger audiences find inspiration in a character who champions unity and understanding. While some detractors criticize the film for what they see as “too woke” an approach, most evidence points to a broader cultural embrace of a redefined, hopeful hero.

Addressing the Skeptics

Not all voices are in agreement, however. A few critics argue that the film prioritizes visual spectacle over deep storytelling, or that the reliance on CGI detracts from its emotional impact. Others worry that emphasizing the immigrant metaphor might alienate viewers who prefer a more traditional take on superhero mythos. Despite these criticisms, the prevailing sentiment remains that Gunn’s Superman is a necessary evolution—a film that dares to remind us of the inherent goodness in the world, even if it does so with a contemporary twist.

Why Superman Still Matters

James Gunn’s Superman (2025) is not just another superhero film. It is a reaffirmation of a cultural icon who has long stood as a symbol of hope, resilience, and the power of kindness. With its engaging storylines, compelling performances, and a fresh narrative that honors the character’s rich history, the film is setting the stage for a vibrant future for the DC Universe.

For longtime fans and newcomers alike, the film serves as a call to remember that in our darkest moments, there is always reason to believe in the light. If you appreciate a balance of heartfelt storytelling and thrilling action, then this reboot is a must-see experience. Visit your local theater, join the conversation online, and embrace the inspiring journey that Superman invites us all to take.